Pulmonary Disorders I
| d. | The RADAR-2 trial also evaluated the conservative and standard of care fluid strategies in critically |
|---|
was not exclusively conducted in ARDS patients, subgroup analysis in ARDS was planned a priori.
In the ARDS subgroup, no differences in mortality, mechanical ventilation duration, or ICU length
of stay were observed between treatment arms. However, it must be noted that the sample size of
ARDS patients in the intervention (n=19) and standard of care (n=11) study groups was very small,
which may limit clinical interpretation for this patient population.
NMBAs
against routine use of NMBAs, the 2024 ATS guidelines do recommend NMBAs in severe ARDS
(P/F ratio less than 100 mm Hg) within 48 hours of ARDS onset with no recommendation for later
Early administration (within 48 hours of ARDS onset) of cisatracurium over 48 hours has consistently
improved oxygenation without increasing the risk of neuromuscular weakness.
The ACURASYS trial showed decreased 90-day adjusted mortality with cisatracurium compared
with placebo (HR 0.68; 95% CI, 0.48β0.98; p=0.04). Subgroup analysis suggested the greatest
mortality benefit in patients with ARDS having a Pao2/Fio2 less than 120 mm Hg. Cisatracurium was
also associated with significantly more ventilator-free days (up to 28 and 90 days) and organ failureβ
free days (up to 28 days). Cisatracurium did not significantly increase the risk of ICU-acquired
| d. | The ROSE trial showed no significant differences in 90-day mortality between cisatracurium |
|---|
(42.5%) and placebo (42.8%) (between-group difference -0.3 percentage points; 95% CI, -6.4 to
5.9; p=0.93). No differences between study groups were found for secondary end points at day 28,
including in-hospital mortality, days free of MV, and days not in the ICU or hospital (N Engl J Med
2019;380:1997-2008).
The optimal strategy for NMBA dosing and monitoring in ARDS remains debatable. The
ACURASYS and ROSE trials had similar dosing strategies of a cisatracurium 15-mg bolus followed
by continuous infusion at 37.5 mg/hour over 48 hours without titration or train-of-four monitoring.
Additional boluses were allowed in patients with elevated plateau pressures (i.e., greater than 30
cm H2O), given concerns for increased risk of ventilator-induced lung injury. However, differing
sedation practices with non-paralyzed patients and lack of proning in the ROSE trial may account
for the differing results.
The ESICM 2023 clinical practice guidelines recommend against routine use of NMBAs in ARDS
CVP
(Recommended)
Pulmonary Artery Occlu-
sion Pressure (optional)
MAP β₯ 60 mm Hg AND No Vasoactive Support β₯ 12 Hr
Urinary Output < 0.5 mL/
kg/hr
Urinary Output β₯ 0.5 mL/
kg/hr
> 8
> 12
Administer furosemide and
reevaluate in 1 hr
Administer furosemide and
reevaluate in 4 hr
4β8
8β12
Administer fluid bolus and
reevaluate in 1 hr
Administer furosemide and
reevaluate in 4 hr
< 4
< 8
Administer fluid bolus and
reevaluate in 1 hr
Monitor and reevaluate in 4
hr
aInitial recommended furosemide dosing = 20-mg bolus or 3-mg/hr infusion. Recommended 2-fold incremental increase in subsequent furosemide doses up to a
maximum of 160-mg bolus/24-mg/hr infusion rate or until goal CVP/pulmonary artery occlusion pressure achieved. See clinical trial publication for further details.
CVP = central venous pressure; MAP = mean arterial pressure.